Problem and a Path
Religious traditions can give a sense of direction. They point to problems – with ourselves and in our world – and they offer a path to set things right. For example:
In Buddhism, the problem is suffering. The reason is selfish craving. A solution is the 8-fold path.
In Jewish and Christian traditions the problem is separation from the love and goodness envisioned in God, and problems that come with living in such a world. The reason, shown in Eden, is human sinfulness or weakness. The path, in Jewish tradition, is following the guidance in the Torah. In Christianity, the focus is acceptance of Christ.
From a religious naturalist perspective, several aspects of a problem can be seen.
On a personal level, varying levels of suffering, anxiety, confusion, and alienation are part of the human condition. We wish for satisfaction, health, peace of mind, and a sense of belonging.
In personal relationships, and among groups and cultures and nations, we have frequent conflict and would like to feel safe and get along with those around us.
In relation to our environment, we observe climate change, destruction of natural areas, and extinctions. We fear that, with overpopulation and pollution, we may permanently damage our home.
In all of this, we seek transformation or re-orientation that will point to a better world. We may also seek salvation – not as defined in Christian doctrine, but as based in the word root, salve, to soothe or heal.
Reasons for the problem
The reasons for these problems can be seen in a naturalist sense of being human, grounded in evolution.
One part is biological, where disease, decline, and death are inevitable parts of life, and where our genetic make-up sets aspects of what we want, how we feel, how we’re inclined to react, and what we do. This includes chemical imbalances that can play roles in mental distress.
Another part is psychological, where the self-conscious awareness that emerged as part of the function of our brains gives the ability to question and doubt. Some confusion and conflict are unavoidable, as we try to determine what is right and balance what is good for ourselves and what is good for our groups.
As advanced primates, our minds and bodies took form through countless generations as hunter/gatherers. Rules of culture formed during centuries of rural life. As technical skills have advanced, our environment has changed – to increasing concrete and noise and diminished contact with nature. Social groups have changed – from lifelong contact with tribes and families to a world increasingly populated with strangers. By controlling disease, population has exploded. We have grown rapidly, with no plan. The lives we live are not the lives our species evolved to.
Paths toward improvement
With no view that a deity shapes what will be, we are on our own. As some aspects of human nature are causes of the problem, other aspects may contribute to solutions.
The best tools we have are knowledge and potential for cooperation and wisdom.
In seeking knowledge, we try to understand elements of problems and how attempts at solutions have succeeded, or not.
An important part of this is self-understanding, with attempts to recognize the implications of traits that we inherited from a pre-human past.
In seeking cooperation, we can act socially and politically to try to move toward approaches that may help.
As we consider issues and make decisions, attempts at wisdom can draw from varied perspectives – some based in evidence from science, some drawing from literature, philosophy, history, parables, and myth – with images to try to move toward.
For personal well-being, we may aspire to enlightenment, self-actualization, mindfulness, and compassion.
For social harmony, we can consider images of utopias and targets for social justice, and we can look to examples in Gandhi, Martin Luther King, Moses, Jesus, and other ancient and modern prophets.
Regarding ecology, we can consider the respect for nature described by Ralph Waldo Emerson, John Muir, Thomas Berry, and many others, and images of balance in a beautiful, sustainable world.
In efforts for transformation, one approach is top down where, by restoring balance to the environment and justice in social relations, personal well-being may improve. Another approach is bottom up where, in improving awareness and actions as individuals, social interactions can improve and environmental preservation may occur.
For those whose religious orientation is not primarily in relation to an active personal God, religious naturalism can give a framework that may contribute to transformation and well-being on personal, social, and environmental levels.
Taking Nature to Heart
A worldview grounded in science that provides a foundation for a way of being in the world that is both inspiring and personally rewarding.